Ameriana Walker, a student in the Wyoming Area School District in northeastern Pennsylvania, demonstrates how a Yondr bag works in September 2025.
Jason Ardan/Citizens’ Voice via Getty Images
hide title
Jason Ardan/Citizens’ Voice via Getty Images
Catch up on what you missed with our educational newsletter, sent weekly.
The rise of smartphones in the United States coincided with a dramatic decline in the reading and math achievement of students in kindergarten through 12th grade. Now, new research suggests that putting students’ phones in locked bags during the school day may help restore some of those historic losses.
“Around 2013, American students began losing 2 to 3 weeks of learning each year,” says Tom Kane of Harvard University, one of the co-authors of the new study. “It’s been a slow leak that, over time, has left U.S. eighth graders nearly a year behind. Strict cell phone bans seem to cover about half of that leak.”
Or the equivalent of 1 or 2 weeks of learning per year, according to the study published Tuesday. This is a small improvement but, according to Kane, statistically significant.
“That could accumulate over time, just as the initial declines did,” adds Douglas Staiger of Dartmouth College, another co-author.
The study’s authors say it is the first nationwide analysis of students’ math and reading test scores before and after schools imposed bans on carrying cell phones with closed bags. It was a joint effort between the Harvard Education Policy Research Center, Dartmouth, and NWEA, a K-12 research and testing organization.
Kane, Staiger and their teams analyzed a nationwide sample of more than 3 million elementary, middle and high school students over the past five school years, comparing test scores in schools that adopted phone cases with scores in similar schools that did not.
The researchers say that not only did strict cell phone bans seem to trigger small gains in learning, but those gains didn’t seem to fade after the first year of implementation. Instead, Kane says, the gains seemed to continue, year after year, at least until three years after the adoption.
Research on phone bans is mixed
Tuesday’s headline finding, that locking phones during the school day led to small but statistically significant improvements in math and reading scores, comes with an important caveat:
A separate study, from April, found that these bags had “almost zero” impact on students’ test scores, and if there was a benefit, it was No statistically significant.
“Overall, we found no evidence of significant improvements in achievement,” says Brian Jacob, co-author of that April study and professor of educational policy at the University of Michigan.
What should we make of these seemingly contradictory results?
Both are large-scale studies conducted by highly respected teams of researchers. The April study has been peer-reviewed; the most recent study has not.
Both studies similarly focused on schools’ adoption of lockable bags made by the for-profit company Yondr. According to Tuesday’s paper, more than 3,300 schools nationwide began using the bags between the ’19-’20 and ’25-’26 school years. Typically, schools that use the bags require students to place their phones in them at the beginning of the day and not retrieve them until the end of the school day, when a school administrator unlocks the bags with a special magnetic device.
But the two studies also differ in key ways. The April study pooled average school-level test scores across several thousand schools that adopted Yondr, while Tuesday’s study used student-level scores across the 844 schools that use both Yondr bags and NWEA-administered tests.
Simply put, the study released Tuesday had more detailed student-level data, but the study released in April was able to examine a much larger sample of schools.
But the findings of the two studies are also not as different as they seem. Jacob and his co-authors found statistically significant gains with Yondr bags in high school math. It’s just that those gains were offset by learning related to the ban. losses in middle school.
Overall, Jacob says, the new study “is encouraging. And if [the benefit] really persists and accumulates over time, it could really be a significant benefit. “I guess we’ll have to wait and see if that happens.”
Another co-author of that April study, Tom Dee, a professor at Stanford University’s Graduate School of Education, says of Tuesday’s findings: “I hope they’re right that these small gains in test scores will add up and add up over time. However, I’m not comfortable making that extrapolation from estimates that are small, sensitive, and based on just a few years of phone bans.”
Overall, Dee says, he finds the results of these early studies on cell phone bans “very disappointing” and insists that “we need continued studies on this topic.”
Kane sees the results differently. Even if the benefit is small, he maintains, relative to the cost (about $25 per student), these bags still make financial sense for schools. “That’s still a lot less than having to pay teachers for an extra week or two of instruction.”
When everything went wrong
For nearly a quarter century, from 1990 to 2013, math achievement among fourth- and eighth-graders rose steadily. Reading scores also improved.
Then, around 2013, student test scores began a sustained decline that continued throughout the COVID-19 pandemic and recently began to decline. For years, politicians and experts blamed losses on school closures during the pandemic, but the data tells a different story.
“Particularly in reading, test scores were going down four to six years before the pandemic,” Stanford University researcher Sean Reardon told NPR earlier this year. “In fact, you wouldn’t really know there was a pandemic effect if you just looked at test scores for the last 10 or 12 years. There’s been kind of a steady decline, regardless of the pandemic.”
Which begs the question: What happened around 2013?
Possible explanations abound. The federal government began to stop holding schools accountable for low test scores. Many schools also suffered funding cuts in the wake of the Great Recession.
This new study is the latest to show that the mass adoption of cell phones by children and teens also helped drive those drops in test scores.
Researchers note that in 2011, less than a quarter of teenage students had access to smartphones. In 2018, 95% did so. And similar rates in other industrialized countries coincided with similar declines in student achievement.
Now, Kane says, he wants to study students’ smartphone and social media use. outside from school.