Apple resisted and opted to remove the ADP feature from UK iPhones rather than comply with the order, and it was later reported that British politicians had abandoned the plan. But while it was public knowledge that the attempt had been made, the Home Office refused to acknowledge it, arguing that revealing the existence of the order would harm national security and the public interest.
Apple itself was not allowed to disclose that it had received a technical capability notice. So far the company has adhered to this, although it comments on the situation in carefully non-specific terms. At one point, for example, he stated that “we have never built a backdoor or master key for any of our products, and we never will,” without actually confirming that he had been ordered to do so in this case.
But now, finally, as TechCrunch reports, the national security argument has been ruled out.
Noting that “anyone with a passing interest in this issue already knows that Defendant has provided a technical capability notice to Apple,” the three judges indicate that they “reject Defendant’s claim that it would be detrimental to national security to confirm the fact that Defendant has given Apple a Technical Capability Notice.”
It should be noted that this ruling refers to the existence of the order rather than its specific details. The judges say that this is “another matter” that “is better addressed separately.” In other words, the case is not over yet.