Schools in New York, Los Angeles and Chicago are considering alternatives to Google after the company said it will disable search in schools that choose not to use its artificial intelligence features, according to The New York Times. Starting next year, schools will not have the option to turn off Gemini features without also turning off Search. Chris Phillips, vice president of education at Google, told Times that “Search and AI are deeply integrated” and that schools that disable Google’s AI features “will not have access to Search.”
Many elected officials, including New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Senator Bernie Sanders, responded harshly, calling Google’s behavior “extortion.” Mamdani had recently announced a policy prohibiting students in grades 2 K to 8 from using AI in the classroom. In a statement to TimesKamar H. Samuels, chancellor of New York City schools, said: “If Google does not reconsider its position, we will explore other search options.” Chicago Public Schools has also reportedly told Google that if it cannot provide a non-AI version of Search, “the district will pursue other search solutions.”
In a statement to The edgeGoogle spokesperson Laura Breen said: “We hear parents’ and teachers’ concerns about students’ use of AI to shortcut learning, and we share the same goal: helping students learn. To improve Search in the classroom, this month we’re starting to test guided learning capabilities in Search to guide students step-by-step through a variety of complex problems, rather than just giving them quick answers. Next year, we’ll also update our approach to controls for schools. to address feedback we’ve heard from educators, so the Gemini app, Gemini Notebook, and Search will be disabled by default until schools decide which services to enable. We are actively building these experiences in partnership with educators, listening closely to ensure our products support students and teachers.”
Educators are wary of AI’s effect on students’ critical thinking skills, and some studies have shown that students who use AI generally perform worse on tests. There are also concerns about the mental health effects of children who develop relationships with chatbots at a young age. But Google is deeply embedded in classrooms across the United States, which rely on Google Classroom, Chromebooks and other services, and removing Google entirely could prove difficult.